quarterback · New York Giants · 23 years old
J.J. McCarthy trade value
Updated November 8, 2026
J.J. McCarthy (QB, New York Giants) has a trade value of 143 in 12-team PPR redraft leagues as of November 8, 2026, ranking QB25 and 155th overall. That is up 143 from 30 days ago.
This season
J.J. McCarthy is averaging 8.7 PPR points a game over 4 of his team's 8 games. That ranks him the QB33 by Fair Shake's season score; the market prices him as the QB25. His trade value is higher than his scoring supports: a market value of 143 against a points value of 105, which makes him a sell-high candidate.
12-team PPR redraft. Points value is what the market pays for players who score like him; buy low, sell high lists the biggest gaps.
Fair 1-for-1 trades
Players at other positions valued within a few percent of J.J. McCarthy in 12-team PPR redraft leagues. Whether a trade helps you depends on both rosters: the trade finder checks that.
QBs valued like J.J. McCarthy
Value by format
| Format (12 teams) | Value | Position rank |
|---|---|---|
| PPR redraft | 143 | QB25 |
| Half PPR redraft | 143 | QB25 |
| Standard redraft | 141 | QB25 |
| Superflex redraft | 939 | QB26 |
| Dynasty (PPR) | 1,006 | QB28 |
| Dynasty Superflex | 1,901 | QB28 |
Trading J.J. McCarthy?
Add your roster and theirs. Fair Shake finds the trades that work for both teams and grades each one.
Questions
What is J.J. McCarthy's trade value?
J.J. McCarthy (QB, New York Giants) has a trade value of 143 in 12-team PPR redraft leagues as of November 8, 2026, ranking QB25 and 155th overall. That is up 143 from 30 days ago.
Is J.J. McCarthy a buy low or a sell high?
J.J. McCarthy is averaging 8.7 PPR points a game over 4 of his team's 8 games. That ranks him the QB33 by Fair Shake's season score; the market prices him as the QB25. His trade value is higher than his scoring supports: a market value of 143 against a points value of 105, which makes him a sell-high candidate. Based on 12-team PPR redraft values as of November 8, 2026.
Who is a fair trade for J.J. McCarthy?
Players at other positions with about the same value in 12-team PPR redraft leagues: RJ Harvey (RB, 142), Keon Coleman (WR, 147), Mark Andrews (TE, 131). Check any trade with your league's scoring in the trade analyzer.